Monday, January 12, 2026

1/15…Labaree’s “Public Goods, Private Goods”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a question about something you didn’t understand or that you’d like to know more about.

33 comments:

  1. Kurt here:
    adfgadfgda

    ReplyDelete
  2. 1. I think the last part of the summary paper was interesting when it said that "Merit and grades distinguish students, but undermine this through homogenizing practices such as grade inflation, social promotion, and whole class instruction.." this is definitely a perspective I hadn't thought of before.
    2. I wonder how this all fits with the idea of private schools, and how it differs from public in the sense of preparedness for the workplace/life/ect?

    ReplyDelete
  3. 1. I find it interesting how Labree talks about social mobility and social efficiency as two goals in strange ways. He talks about “a strange mix in American education, anyone has a possibility to get to the top but with low probability and promoted to the extent that it reduces chances for the lower end to get to the top (opposite of democratic equality)” about social mobility and social efficiency.

    2. I have a question: why do democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility play a role in education for the students? What do we understand from it?
    - Ashley

    ReplyDelete
  4. 1. One thing that really stood out to me is how Labaree explains that schools are basically stuck trying to do multiple, conflicting things at once. We want schools to promote equality and prepare everyone to be active citizens in a democracy, but at the same time schools sort students through grades, tracking, and credentials that end up reinforcing inequality. I had not fully realized how these goals do not just compete with each other, but actually cancel each other out in a lot of ways.

    2. I am still a little confused about Labaree’s solution at the end. When he says education should go back to its core goal of preparing people for political participation and work, I am wondering how realistic that is in a system that is so focused on competition and credentials. What would that actually look like in real classrooms or schools today?

    ReplyDelete
  5. 1. The part that stood out to me the most was how education has since turned into a hunt for academic credentials rather than a desire for knowledge. Social mobility has made academic credentials a desire for students because, for a lot of adults, to succeed in life, education is a primary tool for socioeconomic growth.
    2. I see the role of democratic equality, social efficacy, and social mobility for high school and higher education, but how does it affect elementary and middle education?

    ReplyDelete
  6. 1. One key takeaway I gained from this reading is the true meaning behind social mobility. Previously, if asked I could define the work but the hearing examples such as Schooling becomes primarily about what it can do for individual consumers given by Labaree truely set in the meaning of me.
    2. To take a slightly different approach to answer this question. Something I don't understand is the lack of action from Labaree. Yes, this was highly informative with great information but on the other hand I believe that many people who went to american public would agree with him. People always say actions speak louder than words so with all this knowledge and deep understanding on these issues why not express an actually solution and or game plan?

    ReplyDelete
  7. One thing that stood out to me from Labaree’s article is how strongly the goal of social mobility has taken over American education, making school feel more like a competition for credentials than a place to actually learn or grow as a citizen. I hadn’t fully thought about how focusing on education as a private good benefits individuals but can weaken goals like democratic equality and social efficiency, which are meant to serve the public as a whole. One question I still have is how realistic it is to shift education back toward democratic equality when so many students and families depend on schooling to move up socially, how can schools focus less on credentials without putting people at a disadvantage in a system that still rewards degrees so heavily?

    ReplyDelete
  8. 1. One key takeaway from Labaree's argument is that American education is shaped by competing goals that often have problems with each other. Schools are asked to promote equality, prepare workers, and support social mobility at the same time, but focusing on credentials and competition weakens education's role as a good public service
    2. I didn't fully get Labaree's claim that social mobility is "expressly against equal treatment."if social mobility is supposed to give everyone a chance to move up, why does he argue that is directly conflicts with equality rather than supporting it?

    ReplyDelete
  9. 1. I took away the fact that Labaree is saying that education is more about how many hoops to jump through, or seeing it as a series of achievements to get, rather than the drive to see knowledge or to learn.

    2. I'm a little when he says people/students should be prepared for work. Does he mean the workforce or does he mean for jobs later down the line? If so, then what does public school look like then for elementary, middle school, and high school?

    ReplyDelete
  10. 1. Something that stood out to me is how big of a part social mobility is in the goals of education. Most people don't go to college or get higher education to gain more knowledge anymore, its just to be able to say that one has a degree so they can get a job easier and have a sense of superiority over others.
    2. If the 3 goals of education have problems with each other, how are they still all able to play a role?

    ReplyDelete
  11. 1. One takeaway I got from the article is that the system is set up in a way to set you up for life, mainly in the social efficiency section it spoke about "bending individuals to fit the needs of the workforce."
    2. One question I have is: Why doesn't the school do this in a way to promote creativity? at the end of the day most great ideas and systems come from creativity so why not set up the system in a way that encourages growth for society rather than growth for those at the top?

    ReplyDelete
  12. 1. One thing that I took away from this article was Labaree's argument about how the goal of education as a form of social mobility is "homogenizing" students. I witnessed this in school growing up, as many advanced opportunities slowly became the norm and often even what was expected of students.
    2. After reading this article, I wonder how much standardized testing has played a role in this. I feel as though so many of my classes in K-12 were designed to where I knew strictly what was on the big end of the year standardized test. I was given key words to look for and memorization tricks versus actually learning and interacting with the material in a meaningful way. Because of this I think that I have forgotten so much of that material since I was taught that I would only need it to pass the test.

    ReplyDelete
  13. 1. One thing I learned from the reading is how many problems that need to be solved in the education system, like the lack of material teachers are given, not enough resources for struggling families, and the struggle schools have when people of different social statues, and locations are treated differently.
    2. How does ending bilingual education stabilize American families? And promoting traditional values?

    ReplyDelete
  14. One takeaway from Labaree's article is that American education is heavily focused on social mobility which treats education like a private good. Many people are more focused on getting degrees rather than gaining knowledge and growing. This leads to more competition which goes against equal opportunity, making higher education less equal and against education being a public good. After reading I wonder how education serves as a public and private good if one overpowers the other.

    ReplyDelete
  15. 1) In order for Democracy to function correctly, it's participants need to be educated enough to understand the problems of which they are choosing a candidate over. It's the government's job to make sure that everyone has equal opportunity to become educated.
    2) What does it mean for education to be private good? It makes sense when referring to college since we pay a tuition and in exchange we get instruction and eventually a degree. How can public school be transactional though?

    ReplyDelete
  16. 1. The part that stood out to me the most was when he described public schools as "between political ideals and economic realities." I've never heard it described like that, but it's so true when you think of how teachers typically want to push students in the right direction of bettering the world, while trying to still be aware of many students' realities. During my experience in public schools, it was very easy to sway a certain way, and it was typically on the side of economic realities as people didn't necessarily put their hope in students to change things.

    2. After reading the article, I wondered if this is the same reasoning that those who advocate for more charter and Montessori schools use. Do proponents of these methods use evidence such as this to diminish public schools even though it wasn't what the argument's purpose was? Is it an easier way for public schools to be targeted when most people can agree with the argument in some format, even though they may not agree on the solution?

    ReplyDelete
  17. Something that stuck with me from the reading is the idea of the ways in which the American educational system mutually excludes itself from the unbridled pursuit of knowledge- concerning itself with what Labaree concludes as three categories which interact at odds with each other. It is clear to see that the system of education in the United States is flawed, and Labaree's definitions of democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility as purposes of the system offer an deeper look into why these flaws arise.
    I want to understand better the alternative to what education looks like now. When capitalist ideals are taught in a period of development it is difficult to even conceptualize a way around it, and the need for social efficiency and credentialism becomes a reality that eats itself in a cycle. How do we as a society turn our focus to the "acquisition of knowledge," rather than the "pursuit of credentials," when it really has proven an important skill to socioeconomic "success" to be a productive worker? It seems the education system, along with the entire economic and political system, would need much rewiring.

    ReplyDelete
  18. One takeaway I learned from this article is that "For a long time all boys were trained to be President... Now we are training them to get jobs." It seems to me that the system described in the article is trying to encourage the students not to dream but to focus on the more likely to happen.But Labaree comes up with different ways to argue the purposes of education that doesn't exactly turn students into dreamers but makes things seem a little less dire.
    One question I have is how Labaree expects educators and school systems to implement his ideas. They seem very good on paper, but I wonder how he expects people to use his ideas in practice.

    ReplyDelete
  19. 1. I understood Labaree’s argument as the political implications of what power is in society are chiefly determined in school. We are taught to be obedient, quiet, and good--to follow the structure of the hierarchy of power (teacher-student relationship), which then translates into the real world (employee-boss relationship). The article states, "boys were trained to be president...Now we are training them to get jobs," which supports the societal answer to Labaree's question at the beginning: "Should schools focus on adapting students to the needs of society as currently constructed?” This indicates a shift in societal need: power is distributed among more men rather than concentrated in a select location. All in all, I believe that his argument is correct: you can’t feed the needs of the individual and the needs of society without infringing on the power of the other.

    2. I’m really curious what Labaree would think of Montessori and Waldorf Schools.

    ReplyDelete
  20. 1. One takeaway from this article is that many tensions affect the way education is seen and shaped. Education is a way of revealing how people hope society will develop and what they really think society is.
    2. My question is, how can we as teachers contribute to social mobility and social efficiency?

    ReplyDelete
  21. one thing I took away from this is that the school system really does prioritize grades and credentials over students at the end of the day, even in high school I had friends who were getting ready to fail but teachers and administrators would basically give them freebie grades so they could graduate, but after highschool there's not much for them. I'd like to know WHY as a school system we focus on grades over students genuine future.

    ReplyDelete
  22. 1. What I took away was how the three major goals of American education (democratic equality, social efficiency, and social mobility) often work against one another, which creates a system that struggles to meet any of these goals effectively. What stood out to me was how social mobility has shifted education toward credential-seeking rather than genuine learning.
    2. With grades being as important as they are, how are schools supporting individual needs when they are promoting equal learning, and whole class lessons?

    ReplyDelete
  23. 1.) The takeaway of this article is that the author summarizes how they believe that the educational system has three main principles which are social mobility, democratic equality, and social efficiency. Our system now however, could use some work on focusing on these main principles to prepare students better for the workforce and society.
    2.) A question I have is what steps could we take to implement these principles and make the educational system better.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Roshni
    One specific thing that I learned from this brief reading of the article is that American education is pulled between competing goals. American education is deeply focused on social mobility rather than democratic equality or social efficiency.

    2) If social mobility is so embedded in American education, is it realistically possible to shift schools back toward democratic equality without changing broader economic and social inequalities?

    ReplyDelete
  25. 1. The main point of the article is that the author explains how the education system is built around three core ideas: social mobility, democratic equality, and social efficiency. These principles are meant to help students improve their lives, participate fairly in society, and gain useful skills for the working world. However, the author argues that today’s school system does not always stay focused on these goals. Instead of fully preparing students for real life responsibilities, careers, and active citizenship, the system often falls short. Because of this, the article suggests that education needs to do a better job of reconnecting with these three principles so students can be more successful both in the workforce and in society as a whole.

    2. How would schools support everyone's needs?

    ReplyDelete
  26. One key takeaway from the blog is the tension between education as a public good (benefiting society through informed citizens, social cohesion, and democracy) and as a private good (benefiting individuals through credentials, status, and economic mobility). Labaree explains that although we often talk about education in public-good terms, the system increasingly operates as a private-good marketplace where individuals compete for advantage.

    Question:
    How can schools realistically promote education as a public good when families and students are under so much pressure to pursue education primarily for private benefits like jobs, income, and social status?

    ReplyDelete
  27. Personal there was slot of key point that was made, it will be the Democratic equality, our ancestors fought for us all to be equal in society! This makes sure that all citizens are given the same knowledge and skills.

    My question is, Since Labarees idea was for us to basically be on the sand level, why do modern policies such as SOL testing, school choice, or college admissions reflect the domination of social mobility over democratic equality?
    LaVonte

    ReplyDelete

1/15…Labaree’s “Public Goods, Private Goods”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...