Monday, January 12, 2026

1/29…Traditional and Progressive Schooling

Can you give an example of an experience you have had as a student that seemed traditional? How about progressive? Please very briefly one or the other. Was it a good experience? Why or why not?

32 comments:

  1. My traditional schooling experience came with middle and high school. New ideas weren't pushed as often and the student voice didn't have much of a say. My more progressive experiences came in college. I was expecting long lectures when I came in and little group work but I was very wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I've experienced traditional schooling in college, predominantly last year in lecture halls. It's difficult to sit in a room where the student feels removed from the teacher in the front of the class, especially when it extends for several hours. However hard I try, its constantly requiring my effort to stay focused and continue to take notes. Last year, I took Biology which I also took in high school. I prefered high school biology simply due to the fact that it was far more hands-on and activity based. It's hard to take in so much knowledge at once in a lecture class that has no space for applying it.

    ReplyDelete
  3. For me I would say my more progressive moments in school is here at college in focused inquiry, It is very outside of the box, makes me really think, and very experiential. All my traditional moments were in math all throughout elementary to high school. I would say my most progressive moments in high school was weight training because I was in control of what I was doing 90% of the time and really hands on and translated to my everyday life.

    ReplyDelete
  4. A tradition for me is going to college because I never knew that college biology lectures were very different from my high school biology. When my professor talks or explains a lesson, I don’t understand a thing. I have to go to the tutoring center and PASS for biology. Biology in high school wasn't that hard for me back then; I knew the lesson. College was a huge experience for me, so different from high school because of the different information I got in biology. This is a huge tradition for me with these lectures for biology, History, chemistry and government.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think I got traditional learning all throughout elementary and high school. I was constantly getting homework and sitting through lectures with slides that teachers would read off. In college, my work has really been a lot of talking with peers and thinking outside the box. It's really cool and different, as it allows me to express my thoughts better rather than sticking to a guideline like I did in high school.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I think that it was very informative how in one of the videos it talks about textbooks, and how professors will teach from them and solely the material in them. This has "distinct characteristics of traditional education" which are-that knowledge is a complete product of the past, that it is organized into subject matters, and learnt through transmission. I've experienced this my whole college career, where we are required to buy these textbooks which are often outdated really and the professor will just teach from them and it's like I could learn that just from buying the textbook and reading it? I feel like this isn't a great experience because it takes away from so much more we could learn by looking at multiple resources, talking with each other during discussions etc.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I'd say most of my high school experience was in the traditional learning model. As students, especially at my school, we were just expected to sit and listen to what was being told to us with very little input into what we were actually learning or doing. The "Traditional vs. Progressive" video really put into words how school could feel like a prison at times with the traditional method mixed with constant surveillance. At times, college still feels a little too traditional for my taste, but much better than high school.

    ReplyDelete
  8. My high school experience felt very traditional, many classes were set with desks in rows, gave students little choice, and had strict rules. It wasn’t a good experience because it felt limiting and made school feel more about control than learning.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I actually will use this class as my example! Take my bio class last semester for example. It was a lecture hall of about 100-150 people where the teacher would yap for the whole hour and 15 minutes. It was all note taking, very little hands on experiences, and low teacher student relationship. I would think that this class was the most traditional school setting I have encouraged thus far. The traditional setting causes me to be less attentive because of the lack of connection from peers and the professor Now take this class for example. Although it was just started I have not know so many peoples name in my class since high school. The open ended discussion foundation of this class is very progressive and I would like to believe is very democratic because we all have different life's/ experiences which influences our ideas which causes us to learn from each other which I personally think has been a great experiences thus far.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Part of my schooling that seemed traditional was my first year of college. Most of my classes were big lecture style classes where it was 3 tests and a final making up the whole grade. This was not a very good experience because it was difficult to get help in a class and the material combined with the lecture style class is not usually very engaging. A more progressive experience for me was being able to take a lot of online classes last semester. This worked out good for me because I was very sick for a while but did not want to skip the semester. It also offered lots of time flexibility, but it did come with a lot of downsides too.

    ReplyDelete
  11. In high school, my AP classes felt very traditional. Even though there were writing portions that were meant to push students to think and interact more deeply with the material, AP grading looks for keywords and therefore I was taught almost script-like answers. The classes I am taking in college are much more progressive. Specifically my English classes, I feel as though I am having the opportunity to interact with material in a way that is productive to myself and my own learning experience. I do not enjoy the way AP classes are formulated and did not feel as though I actually took much away from the experience. Now I feel like I'm learning actual skills as opposed to just arbitrary facts.

    ReplyDelete
  12. For the most part I've had experiences with traditional learning in elementary, middle, and high school. But from time to time I've experienced teachers who facilitate the students to reflect and teach themselves on what is being taught, so that it can be applied not just to tests, but real word experiences. A clear example of this was my government class in high school. We learned about the structure of the government of course, but we were also given opportunities to form arguments, debate in class, and critically think for ourselves. For me it was a great experience!

    ReplyDelete
  13. One progressive experience I’ve had as a student was being in a class where discussions, group work, and personal reflection were a big part of learning. As a Black girl, I felt more comfortable sharing my opinions and connecting lessons to my own experiences, especially when topics related to identity or social issues came up. It was a good experience for me because it made learning feel meaningful, and I felt respected and included rather than silenced.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Most of my classes in high school were traditional. Especially my math, history, and physics classes which felt very lecture and paperwork heavy. Even though group work was possible, none of it required too much out of the box thinking. Although, a couple of my high school teachers went a more progressive route with their teaching. In college, my professors are either super traditional or focus on being progressive. My last semester’s biology class and this semester’s chemistry class are insanely lecture heavy and don’t involve any group discussion. The entirety of the class is looking up at the board, taking notes, and passing quizzes and tests. Something such as my education based classes in college are way more progressive since they have discussions that relate to the current world, among many other things.

    ReplyDelete
  15. When I lived in Pennsylvania, my middle school science program would give us pretests before each unit. If we got an A on the pretest, instead of spending the next few weeks in classroom lectures, we would be sent to this special room down the hall to work on a self guided project loosely based on the unit. I aced the geology pretest and decided to make a presentation on asteroids.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. (This is an example of progressive)

      Delete
  16. An example of traditional learning I’ve experienced is in math class. We read and did work in the text book and were encouraged to just do the math based on the text book. A progressive learning experience I’ve had was in my tenth grade English class when we read a lot of classics and were expected to come up with original ideas about them. I think that both experiences benefits the classes that I was in. If I had a progressive style of learning for math class, I feel like it would be harder to understand and the same for if English was traditional. It would be more difficult to learn about Julius Caesar by William Shakespeare if I was just reading about the play from a textbook and not coming up with my own ideas and acting out the play as the class.

    ReplyDelete
  17. I would say most of my high school experiences were traditional, with mostly lectures and built-in tests and quizzes. It was a fine experience because it allowed for structured learning, but it didn’t really allow for much creativity or engagement. Personally, I enjoy more hands-on subjects and activities, which I experienced more in my science classes in junior and senior year through labs and dissections.

    ReplyDelete
  18. One experience that I had at school that seemed progressive was that we had a science class for students that weren't as strong in science called "river." During this class we would go on trips to different parks around Richmond. This class was offered during senior year of high school and it gave seniors an opportunity to get outside and learn things that most high schools don't offer in a low pressure environment.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I had a lot of progressive ways of teaching, my teachers were always teaching in different ways like in my English class my teacher would use fun ways to get us active like using games to help learn the book we’re learning, when we read Hamlet he let us act out the character like a play and in art we went to a fruit trip to pub locally paint on glass.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Edit: I had a lot of progressive experiences of teaching, my teachers were always teaching in different ways like in my English class my teacher would use fun ways to get us active like using games to help learn the book we’re learning, when we read Hamlet he let us act out the character like a play and in art we went to a field trip to publicly paint on glass.
      —Nevaeh J.

      Delete
  20. I would say that a traditional learning experience I had was definitely was lecture based learning, especially in college classes last semester. Most of the time, the teachers would just read off the slides, and I would sit there and listen, taking notes so I could be prepared for the tests or quizzes we had. This was somewhat effective; however, we weren’t engaging in much hands-on learning, and it also lacked engagement. I would say the progressive learning really started to kick in when we would do projects or group work. Very similarly, I could reflect on my time in high school, some classes felt very traditional, while my science classes or my electives felt more progressive

    ReplyDelete
  21. One traditional experience I had as a student was sitting in rows while the teacher talked and we wrote notes the whole class. I learned the lesson, but it was boring and I didn’t get to talk much or share my ideas. A more progressive experience was working in small groups to solve real-life problems and then talking about our answers with the class. That was a better experience because it made learning more fun and helped me understand the topic more.

    ReplyDelete
  22. One traditional experience I had as a student was sitting quietly while the teacher lectured and we copied notes or completed worksheets. It felt very structured, but it wasn’t always a good experience because there wasn’t much room to ask questions or learn in different ways.
    A more progressive experience I had was working in small groups on projects where we could talk, problem solve, and share ideas. That was a good experience because it felt more engaging and helped me understand the material better.

    ReplyDelete
  23. My schooling experience was split between public and private education. In my public elementary school tradition tactics were enforced heavily. A large portion of the school was located in a low-income area. I realized that teachers were harder because of this. There was no student choice or free will. From here, I moved to a small Quaker school where free choice and progressive teaching were the norm. We had the ability to pick what we learned. A lot of it was group work and student-led. This experience was fantastic, I learn what my ideal learning environment and style i need during this time.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Harriet Mullen-CraggFebruary 2, 2026 at 4:15 PM

    In Middle School, I believe that I had more of a traditional school learning, but as I went onto High School and joined IB, things turned to progressive learning and included more hands-on and interactive. In Middle School, I found that I was less interested in lessons and was (to put it nicely) miserable. In a progressive learning environment, I became closer to the teachers, was more invested in my education and I genuinely enjoyed learning new things.

    ReplyDelete
  25. throughout my 13 years in public school I have had both progressive and traditional learning experiences, but overall my experience was traditional. I thought it would be a good idea to do duel enrollment in 10th grade, and lets just say it was work. So many lectures and papers, and the lectures are so long. Now, while it was not the best experience, it most definitely had me prepared for college and I am now having an easier time here than in high school classes. But at the end of the day I was able to go to my elective and just reset and regroup, if I didn't have those classes I feel highschool would have looked very different, or I would still be stuck there.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Hey hey I do believe that throughout my years of school I had a good amount of different teaching, it was mostly traditional and does it work. its was just a lot of handouts, lectures, and talking. I also went to a private performing arts school so that was more progressive because it was small group and we worked together on different things. I believe that overall I had good teachers and wouldn't change anything. - Lavonte

    ReplyDelete
  27. Throughout my years in public school, I believe that most of my teachers taught in a traditional style. For example, I would sit in my honors-level and AP classes and I would silently take detailed notes based on just my teacher's lecture and words. In my elective classes that had more creativity, I was able to work in groups and have discussion-based class periods, which I'd say is more progressive. I personally was a kid who loved school and idolized my teachers, so I had an overall good experience!

    ReplyDelete
  28. In most of my school years, I feel like I've had a more progressive learning environment. For most of high school, almost all my classes were hands-on, and students had much more creative freedom. I grew closer to my teachers, became more invested in my education, and genuinely enjoyed learning new things. I also worked in the office during my junior and senior years, which helped me hone my professional skills.

    ReplyDelete

1/15…Labaree’s “Public Goods, Private Goods”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...