What was school discipline like where you went to school? Looking back, can you remember any teachers who did a particularly good job of managing their class? What did they do/not do?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1/15…Labaree’s “Public Goods, Private Goods”
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any ot...
-
Think back to your own experiences as a student. Can you identify any places where you see the influence of an asset approach. Can you recal...
I feel like discipline at my school was never really that serious. It was getting yelled at. ISR. maybe a call home. But nobody was ever expelled or anything. Teachers who did a good job would joke with students when they got in trouble. Most times the students respected the teachers more after getting joked with rather than scolded.
ReplyDeleteWhen I was at private school we had like a "demerit system" where if you got to 10 demerits you had detention. It was like cheating was an automatic 10, lying counted as a few, disrespect counted as a few, just stuff like that. Everybody thought it was so old fashioned and dumb and like nobody even wanted to be at that school so we all kinda just dealt with it. One teacher I specifically remember, though she was good about discipline, she was my fifth grade teacher, and if a student did something wrong, she never called them out in front of everyone she would pull you aside and talk to you about what happened privately. She never wanted to embarrass you or make your business the whole classes.
ReplyDeleteAt my high school, discipline was pretty strict because it was a Catholic school. There were clear rules about things like behavior, dress code, and respect, and teachers actually enforced them. If you broke a rule, there were consequences like detention or a call home. At the time, it felt a little much, but looking back, it helped keep things under control and made it easier to focus on school. Everyone kind of knew what was expected, and that made the environment more serious and focused on learning.
ReplyDeleteThere were definitely teachers who stood out when it came to managing their classrooms. The best ones weren’t just strict—they were fair and respectful. They made their expectations clear from the start and stayed consistent, but they didn’t yell or embarrass students. They handled problems calmly and treated us like we mattered. They also made class interesting, which helped a lot because when students are engaged, they’re less likely to act out. You could tell they actually cared about us and wanted us to succeed, and that made us respect them more. Looking back, they had a good balance between being in control and being supportive.
Whenever I think about classroom management and discipline my brain immediately goes to elementary school and when the teachers would have the charts on the wall with green yellow and red behavior with clips with everyones name. This was traumatic and literally a form of public humiliation. But the reason if comes to mind so quickly is because it worked so well or me. I remember being terrified to have my clip get moved down a notch so I would always behave. However, I don't think this is a great way to manage a classroom at all. Its very emotional straining for children and I think teachers that use this are just not confrontational so they view it is a easy solution but in the long run they're not fixing anything.
ReplyDeleteThese two events were when I remember how my teacher and a substitute teacher handled a solution in my class once. In high school, in my senior year, there were two boys, and this girl always caused trouble by not doing their work or being on their phone. Other girls always talk back to the teacher or leave the classroom with the teacher's permission. My teacher always checks whether they are doing their work when another girl leaves the classroom, and she either calls the security officer or informs someone about the girl. At another event at the 6th-grade elementary school, my teacher was not going to be in my classroom all day. We have a substitute teacher watching my class, and we come back from another class. These two boys started fighting, and my substitute teacher couldn't handle the situation, so she went to find another teacher to help. I was shocked that she went to get help because she didn't know how to handle this situation.
ReplyDeleteOne of my teachers that did a great job at managing our class was my river teacher. He allowed us to ask questions and participate in open disscusions. He was firm with the students that were messing around but he was also very forgiving and understanding. He treated us like adults and allowed us to collaborate with each other and with him. It was clear that he had high expectations of how we should act but he didn't have to yell or punish us in order to get us to live up to those expectations. I've had many experiences especially in elementary school where I felt like the class was being micro-managed and the teachers didn't leave room for us to make mistakes and learn from those mistakes. It's important for me to give students the space to mess up and try again without feeling like they will be ostracized or screamed at.
ReplyDeleteIn my experience, discipline in high school felt strict but not fair. A lot of the focus was on small things like being a little late or taking too long in the bathroom, and the teachers would call you out in front of the class, but things like students barely showing up or not doing any work were not called out. It felt like they were being strict without really understanding what students might be dealing with behind the scenes. One teacher who stood out to me was my English teacher because she balanced discipline with understanding. She held students accountable if they weren’t doing anything, but if you were trying, she was more supportive. Instead of embarrassing students in front of the class, she would talk to you privately and actually listen, which made students respect her more and take responsibility.
ReplyDeleteI’m my experience, the discipline in my schools was pretty weak. There was more effective punishment in elementary school like getting sent to the principals or getting pulled out of class but as I got older the only discipline was detention or suspension. I honestly did not have many situations where teachers needed to be super discipline, a lot of my classmates were respectful. I think the only thing that seemed to make a difference was in elementary school when kids got pulled out of class or something similar.
ReplyDeleteMy high school disciple was very strict. Students would get suspended for the little thing. I hate that even when you stand up for yourself you still would get suspended. Sometimes some students needed that discipline because they did things wrong and they would be disrespectful to a teacher. Some teachers couldn't get there class in check some could and didn't mind sending you outta there classroom.
ReplyDelete-Lavonte Evans
DeleteIn my school district, discipline was enforced heavily. I remember in middle and high school when each of the students was given a code of conduct that had to be brought home and signed by a parent to make sure that the rules were understood. To manage classes I did see some teachers using deficit approaches. I noticed that if students were perceived to be in the the "bad" crowd or even converse with those in that crowd, teachers would be reluctant to allow these students to go to the bathroom for fear that they might "cause trouble" or they might withhold certain privileges due only to these preconceived notions. I witnesses the faculty bullying students more than actually standing up for students who were bullied, but maybe that's only my experience...
ReplyDeleteI think teachers did a bad job with discipline in school. Instead of realizing that there might be something wrong with a child, they just shame the kids for being late, submitting things late, etc. I think that teachers should try to care more about the kids who don't care. I mean I'm sure it's difficult but caring does a lot for kids. I think a lot of students just know that their teachers do not care.
ReplyDeleteFor most of my time in school there has been little bad instances, the kids I was with was pretty behaved so I'd say my teachers had things handled and managed. In those few instances all but one were they able to get the class under control whether that was with threats to take away something precious like in elementary school, or make things harder assignment wise in like MS to HS. Discipline in elementary and middle was really just taking away anything fun that was going on in the school, sometimes in high school as well. But in high school for the most part those who misbehaved were typically just given detention or some sort of constraint to curb their behavior.
ReplyDeleteFor most of time time during school, most teachers used simple rules like raising your hand before speaking, staying in your seat, and turning work in on time. If students broke the rules, the punishment was usually something small like a warning, moving seats, staying after class for a few minutes, or sometimes a call home. Looking back, the teachers who did the best job managing their class were not the ones who yelled the most, but the ones who stayed calm and consistent. They made their expectations clear from the first day, reminded students of the rules in a respectful way, and treated everyone fairly. One teacher I remember did a really good job because she kept the class busy with interesting work, so students did not have much time to get distracted. She also talked to students privately when there was a problem instead of embarrassing them in front of everyone. What she did not do was overreact or punish the whole class for one person’s mistake, which helped students trust and respect her more. Because of that, her classroom felt organized, safe, and easier to learn in.
ReplyDeleteMy school was all over the place, some kids would get suspended, ISS, but they never got expelled. Instead, what my school used to do was they would actually send the kid to the closest school from where the parent is, or the default school which was Mountain View.
ReplyDeleteMy freshman year at Fairfax, they definitely were more lenient with students, and just mostly gave everyone 1-3 days ISS, sometimes after school detention. However my junior and senior year, they were pretty harsh, even when I got in trouble at times.
I feel like discipline at my school was never that serious. I knew a couple students who would get in school suspension every once in a while and a few people who got expelled and had to go to alternative school. But just discipline in the classroom, there was never really that much, especially after COVID a lot of teachers just stopped caring about students behaving. Before that maybe they would give you a lunch detention or something but I feel like there wasn't much discipline at my school.
ReplyDeleteDiscipline at my school was always 50/50. There were certain things that always got a serious consequence like fighting or having any banned substances, but other things that they always brushed off and nothing really changed from it. There was a lot of ISS, which didn't really help because kids would either just not go and there wasn't much the teachers could do about it, or they'd go and play on their phones the whole time which was the opposite of a punishment for them. The stern teachers always had the easiest time managing their class, because even though they weren't mean, they still had standards that were required to be met and even if the students didn't like it, they still followed. I did notice that the male teachers always had an easier time with discipline and classroom management, and I would never hear many problems about them. The one female teacher that didn't have a problem was the teacher no one liked (and rightfully so), so I think it was interesting how at my school at least it had to go that far.
ReplyDeleteAt my elementary school, we used a “flip a card” system for discipline, and it worked pretty well. Everyone started on green, and if you misbehaved, you’d flip to yellow, then red, with consequences like losing recess, eating lunch alone, or a call home. It was clear and fair, so most students understood the rules.
ReplyDeleteThe teachers who managed their class best were calm and consistent. They didn’t yell a lot, and they followed through with consequences every time. They also focused on rewarding good behavior, not just punishing bad behavior, which for the most part made students actually want to behave.
Discipline always felt a little strange in certain scenarios. I didn’t get punished much but when I did a lot of times I wouldn’t understand what I did wrong. In elementary school if a kid did something wrong then they’d be sat down to write a paper during recess. I’m not sure how effective I can call that method but it’s better than other forms of discipline. What I don’t like is when one kid does something wrong then the whole class gets punished. That tended to happen a lot during my K-12 experience.
ReplyDeleteFor me, the discipline wasn't ever harsh. I guess that could be because I tried to stay out of trouble, though I did witness other students getting disciplined. There were more students of color that were disciplined, and this happened with ISR, ISS, and in extreme cases sending students to a neighboring alternative school. In elementary school I remember the common modality was clothespins on either green, yellow, or red. I also remember in high school it was not allowed to walk around the hallways during class time. While this was understandable, there were also times when we had projects in our classes that required us to walk around (i.e. filmmaking, reporting.) It was frustrating having school officers and teachers getting upset with us before we even got a chance to explain that our idling was teacher-enacted.
ReplyDeleteGrowing up, classroom management in elementary school focused a lot more on the class as a group and punishments were often more universal even if it was only the fault of a few students. By middle and high school though, punishments became particular to the individuals causing problems. I think that this is a more effective way to handle issues in the classroom because it helps to weed out the true problem and also allows for communication between teacher and student in this case of extenuating circumstances.
ReplyDeleteFor me, I feel like the discipline was never really that serious. I rarely heard about students getting suspended but my school was very serious about having phones out and they would take it away and if it kept happening, then the parents would have to come get them. I personally think it's stupid. I get why teachers would get frustrated but at the same time, like, you never know why a student is on their phone; it could be very serious and taking it away is not helping their situation.These incidents would happen in high school. My elementary and middle school punishments were not really there. My school mainly focused on rewarding good behavior that students were doing any rarly any bad behavior.
ReplyDeleteHonestly where I went to school discipline really just depended on the teacher. Like some classes were super strict where you couldn’t even talk without getting in trouble, and then other classes were so relaxed that nobody really cared and it got kind of out of control. It didn’t feel like the school itself was consistent, it was more just each teacher doing their own thing.
ReplyDeleteThe teachers who actually handled their class well weren’t even the strictest ones. It was more the ones who were just consistent and fair. Like they didn’t randomly change rules or only get on certain people. You kinda always knew what would happen if you did something, so it made it easier to just not mess around.
Also the good teachers didn’t yell all the time. The ones who yelled a lot were usually the ones losing control, cause people would just stop listening or start pushing it more. The better ones stayed calm but still made it clear they weren’t playing. If someone was being annoying they’d deal with it quick and not make a huge scene.
And they actually treated us like real people. Not in a fake way but like they had some respect for students, so it made you not want to act stupid in their class. It wasn’t even really about getting in trouble, it was more like you didn’t want to disappoint them which sounds kinda dumb but it’s true.
Looking back the worst teachers were either way too strict for no reason or way too chill with no structure at all. The ones in the middle who had clear expectations and were fair are the ones whose classes actually worked.
I remember in elementary school, teachers were mean! At least that's how it felt. In 8th grade, I went back to volunteer, and I noticed that nothing had changed. I went to a majority-black elementary school that served the poorest part of the city. The teachers definitely took this and ran with it. They played into the system, and unfortunately, the effects could still be seen years later. There was a lot of yelling, belittling, and punishment that wasn't necessary.
ReplyDeleteA lot of the behavior control in my elementary school seemed Authoritarian at best. I remember at lunch we had an arbitrary volume level (decided by our lunch monitor) that if we exceeded we'd have to spend the rest of lunch in silence. If anyone popped their bag of chips the lunch monitor would hunt them down and if she failed we'd all have to wait an extra 5 minutes before going out to recess. My 3rd grade teacher however was very good dealing with our behaviors. There was a lot of dynamic teaching techniques that kept everyone busy while she focused on 3 or 4 of us at a time and she'd read us books like "The Land of Stories" that seemed to be the perfect amount of action and adventure to keep us engaged.
ReplyDeleteThe worst level of discipline I remember in school for me was in my private elementary school, where teachers would almost bully students if they weren't doing things correctly. The worst I remember it being is my mathematics teacher threatening to hit a student with a ruler because of them telling another student to "shut up." I do think that this was extremely harsh and not correct in any manner, and looking back at it now, I laugh at how pressed my teachers were, but I definitely think that teachers were given too much power in that sense, given their students were struggling and failing without any help at all.
ReplyDeleteI feel like discipline at my school was never that serious. I knew a couple students who would get in school suspension every once in a while and a few people who got into fights and had to go to alternative school. But just discipline in the classroom, there was never really that much, until the phone ban most of the teachers just stopped caring about students behaving.
ReplyDeleteWe didn’t really play around at my highschool, it was always out of school suspension or in school suspension no in between i hated it
ReplyDelete