Monday, January 12, 2026

3/3…Instruments of a Beating Heart

React to the documentary. Some possible topics: share something about how the documentary made you feel. Were you surprised by any of it? What does it say about the purposes of school in Japan? How does it compare to the purposes of school in the U.S.?

27 comments:

  1. Watching this documentary, it reminded me of growing up playing travel volleyball. I witnessed this form of "tough love" many times and I've come to realize the difference between succesful tough love and unsuccesful tough love is whether the person being tough has built a relationship with the player or the student. This led me to really think about how I want to be as a teacher and how I can push my students without making them want to quit. It made me uncomfortable to watch the documentary because I understood what the girl felt and how upset she was, but while talking with the Japanese students, I realized this is how most Japanese schools are and oftentimes, the teachers lack a close relationship with the students. This is not really how it is in the U.S. because most of the time, teachers form relationships and are very friendly with their students.

    ReplyDelete
  2. While watching the documentary, I felt uncomfortable at times because I could see how upset the girl was, and I understood that feeling. It made me think about my own experiences growing up while being a dancer. Sometimes it really helps dancers improve, but other times it just makes them feel small or discouraged. I’ve learned that the difference is the relationship. When a teacher truly cares about you and takes time to know you, their strictness feels like support. But when there isn’t a strong connection, it can feel harsh and lonely. The documentary also made me reflect on the conversations about Japanese schools. It seems like in many of those schools, teachers are more distant and don’t always build close relationships with students. That’s different from what I’ve usually seen in the U.S., where many teachers try to be friendly and form real connections. Watching this made me think about the kind of teacher I want to become. I want to push my students to work hard and grow, but I also want them to feel supported so they don’t lose confidence or want to quit.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Watching the documentary made me uncomfortable like most others in the class. Watching a teacher yell at a kid is just EUUGH it doesn't sit right with me. I think schooling in Japan is very different from the US because it's sort of teaching you social things to prepare for in the real world not just education. In most jobs you'll likely get yelled at by your boss or something like that. I think many schools in america are too gentle but schools in Japan teachers act more like parents

    ReplyDelete
  4. Watching this documentary, I found myself feeling a tad uncomfortable, but not surprised by the way that the children were treated. Although harsh, I thought of the teachers actions being something similar to tough love and that push that the kids needed to be successful. I think this is different in the US with the way that teachers want to have a positive relationship with their students and pride themselves on concepts like "teacher of the year." In a way, I do think that kinder teachers have, while boosting people's confidence, made students incapable of receiving criticism or accepting failure as an opportunity to grow.

    ReplyDelete
  5. The documentary made me feel empathy toward Ayame, but it also made me feel proud. She first tried out for the drums but didn’t get the part, and she was very sad about it. However, she had the strength to try again. I was surprised by the level of accountability they teach in Japanese schools at just grade 2. When I was in grade 2, we had line leaders and behavior charts, but we did not have anything like this.

    In my opinion, this shows that the purpose of schools in Japan is to build responsibility, accountability, and a strong work ethic from a young age for the betterment of Japanese society. In the US, I feel that the purpose of school has the same intent but a different execution, which is why I think that, as a society, we might be lacking because of it.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I personally deal with this to this day. I know that my teacher want the best for me and my craft. I understand that it might make me wanna cry but I know that I need to go to practice room and do some more practice. I think that we have to look at the bigger picture although she cried she got back up and tried again and got a good outcome.

    ReplyDelete
  7. When I watched the film I first noticed how slightly harsh the music teacher was, at first I wanted to say he was too mean but then I remember in my music/chorus class—Mrs. Simmons threw chalk at us if we got a note wrong, and the one common thing Mrs. Simmons and the music teacher had. They just wanted their students to get better, they care just in upper case letter lets and tough love. The only difference I spotted was the Japanese students didn’t eat in classrooms, they served each other food and cleaned there school and changed there shoes. American school don’t do that, it makes me feel America is super lazy and have no regard for high school and middle school care for the building. That’s why all the schools I went to were dirty, and god forbid you accidentally touch the floor.

    —Nevaeh J.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I found the discipline of the teacher towards the student to be mildly uncomfortable at first- though when I thought about it more and saw the evolution of the documentary, it was clear to me that this sort of discipline had helped the child to feel autonomous over her own success. This certain dynamic is not as present in United States education, although the documentary made me think that perhaps it should be. The girl was messing up the song, and the teacher knew that she was not practicing as much as she should have been. He was harsh, but also was an educator that pushed her to care more and apply herself more deeply to the task at hand. I think sometimes young children need more guidance than our society might think.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I thought this documentary was really cool especially watching it with the Japanese students. It was really interesting to learn about how their schools are different compared to schools in the US. It was a little different at sometimes especially with the "tough love" and it was kind of sad, because I felt bad for the little girl. But it all worked out in the end and I do think that that might've been an effective method. I think maybe sometimes in the US people are maybe too gentle at times and then you never find out the other person or child's full abilities because maybe sometimes you have to be pushed to get there.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Watching the documentary made me feel so sad for the little girl, but also really proud of her at the end. This made me feel like schools in Japan care more about student success than in the US because even though the music teacher was being very tough on her, he was acting that way because he wanted to see her succeed. And the other teacher that was comforting her when she was feeling sad, Ive never seen teachers like that in my time in the US. I think in the US, a lot of teachers, not all, but a lot of them view teaching as just a job instead of viewing it as actually teaching and preparing kids for the future.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Watching this documentary made me realize how much the students really wanted a certain instrument and tried so hard but didn't get it and got something else. Another thing is I really liked how this one boy was crying with joy because his friend got chosen to play a certain instrument. The teachers were a little strict but at the end they reassured them and said things like, "look at what you did, you did that." I think the teachers in the US are way too gentle with students and don't really push them much.

    ReplyDelete
  12. The documentary was really intriguing to me, especially because I asked one of the Japanese students if it was similar to what they experienced, and they said yes. That made the documentary feel more realistic. In Japan, it seems much more normal to be strict and put pressure on younger students because there are high expectations for them. In the U.S. today, I feel like teachers are sometimes afraid to push students too much, even if it would help them grow and do better. One thing that surprised me the most was seeing the students clean their own school. It showed that they’re trusted and seen as capable of handling responsibility, even at a young age.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I enjoyed the documentary we watched in class and appreciated the opportunity to watch it alongside the Japanese students. First, I felt bad for the little girl who was often crying, but in the end I realized the bigger picture was to show that although teachers can be harsh, they know what will best help their students succeed. This didn't really surprise me because I think, depending on what teachers you have, this can also be experienced in America. Something that surprised me when talking with the Japanese students was how the students serve meals to other students. Here in America, we are very familiar with the cafeteria setting with lunch lines, but in Japan they said lunch is served by students.

    ReplyDelete
  14. The documentary made me feel very sad for the little girl. I always hated when teachers in elementary school were so mean to the kids that they would cry. I was surprised that the rest of the students were acting totally normal and not like their classmate was crying in front of them. As for a purpose, it was to encourage the little girl and make her a better music player. In american schools, the purpose is to get you out of the school system as cheaply as possible while maintaining a school average to get state funding.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I enjoyed the documentary it was very funny and cute. I felt for the girl because in my experience I've gone through the same thing ie my music teacher making me cry. It showed that mean/intimidating music teachers exist all over. But watching the documentary was heartwarming seeing how much the other students cared for each other. Even more sweet to see how much the teacher valued the students endeavors. Though the order and the way a school day is structured is different than here in the states, organization is still maintained and prioritized. It also shows the universal care and love by teachers for their students.

    ReplyDelete
  16. When I was watching the documentary, I thought the teacher was being how a teacher should be. Making sure you excel in the best way you can, parents in the US if you ever said anything like that to their child, it would be a whole thing to the point you almost lose your job. The teachers in Japan want you to excel in whatever it is you are doing big or small and the way the homeroom teacher had so much care for her students really show that when they are being "tough" they are doing it with love.

    ReplyDelete
  17. While watching the documentary, more things felt similar to my experiences than I would have expected. There were some major differences such as the joint effort in cleaning every day and the way lunch worked, but the teacher-student relationship felt familiar. Personally, I don't think that the music teacher was being mean to the little girl. Sure, he was a little strict, but that's always been my experience. He didn't yell, belittle her, or exclude her, he just simply laid out his expectations and expected her to put in the appropriate effort for them to be met. It was a tough love, and any six-year-old may be upset the way she was, but the community that was throughout the school is what pushed her through.

    ReplyDelete
  18. While watching the documentary in class my fist would tighten. I would clench my jaw. I couldn't help but feel for the little girl. Although I thought the discipline from the teacher was for the greater good and beneficial her tears made me feel a certain type of way. It surprised me how much the little kids cared about their classmates performance and how they all supported one another at an early age. In my opinion the purpose of schools in the US is to just push you to the next phase of life. Weather that be gaining a higher education or into the workforce. Japan however I get the sense that they want to shape students into a stricter mold/ member of society.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I was a little surprised by how the teacher reacted and disciplined the children throughout the day. If teachers here did that, they would be shamed by parents. I do think though, it was constructive. It felt more like how a parent treats their child. I really liked how the students cleaned and served each other. It reminds me of how students in Montessori work together. this to me, says the purpose of school to better the whole rather than the individual. Which doesn't differ from the reasoning for schooling in the U.S. but the approach is much different.

    ReplyDelete
  20. The documentary Instruments of a Beating Heart made me feel both inspired and a little emotional. It showed how much effort and responsibility the students in Japan put into something as simple as a school performance. I was surprised by how seriously the teachers and students took practicing the music and how they focused on teamwork, discipline, and how they never gave up. Even when some students struggled, the goal wasn’t just to get it perfect but to learn how to keep trying and support each other.

    ReplyDelete
  21. The documentary definitely tugged on my heartstrings, but after really thinking about it, I agree with the more intense ways of teaching they used. My memories of elementary school were very chaotic, and there were times that this sort of discipline could have been very useful to improve the learning of the class as a whole. I think that the documentary did an excellent job of showing the uncomfortable part of the method, but the productive result it produced as well.

    ReplyDelete
  22. My reaction to the documentary was very shocking because it is very different from the US. When the teacher was too mean and strict to the girl. I feel sad for the girl because she just messed up. I love seeing her other teachers support her, and she is trying her best to improve. I was surprised by how strict the teacher was. The purpose was to ensure the student had their role for the performance, and their goal was not to mess up on the day of the performance. Students should know that they were not lucky to get their role; they had to work hard to earn it. The purpose of U.S. students is to pass the grade and the standard test. That is how I see the purpose, but I can be wrong.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Watching Instruments of a Beating Heart made me feel emotional and proud of Ayame. When she didn’t get chosen to play the drums at first, she was really sad, but she didn’t give up. Instead, she tried again, which showed how strong and determined she was. That part stood out to me the most. I was also surprised by how much responsibility second graders have in Japan. When I was in second grade, we had things like line leaders and behavior charts, but nothing this serious. In Japan, it seems like schools focus a lot on teaching kids to be responsible and work hard from a young age. In the U.S., I think schools want students to learn the same values, but they do it in a different way. Because of that, students may not learn responsibility as early. This documentary helped me see how schools in different countries prepare students in different ways.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Watching this documentary honestly made me feel kind of emotional. It was hard seeing such young kids carry that much pressure, especially knowing how seriously they took their roles. I felt proud of them, but also a little uncomfortable at times. You could tell how much it mattered to everyone that they got it right, and that weight felt heavy for elementary schoolers.

    I was surprised by how much the focus was not just on music, but on discipline, teamwork, and responsibility. It seemed like the real purpose of school in Japan, at least in this documentary, was to build character and teach students how to function as part of a group. Success was not just about individual talent. It was about not letting the group down.

    Compared to schools in the U.S., it feels different. Here, we talk a lot about self expression and individual achievement. In the documentary, it felt like the priority was unity and collective success. Neither approach is perfect, but it made me realize how much school reflects what a culture values.

    ReplyDelete
  25. In the documentary, I was very surprised by how well oriented and the kids were in the school. I did feel really bad for the kid, because that kid cried at least like four times. However, her character was built up and she even gained confidence at the end, to me it felt like when I was wrestling in high school. There were times where confidence broke, and you thought you wouldn't push through, but in the end it was worth it.

    I think the difference is definitely that they are more discipline focused, and want the kids to do their very best in anything they do, even pushing them to their absolute limits for their potential.

    ReplyDelete
  26. My favorite part of this documentary was the end, where all the kids came to realize they were all a part of a whole heart. I believed this scene represented the documentary by representing the community within a school that takes for a kid to grow into their knowledge, and how a student represents a part of the community around them. While some may be bothered by the discipline from the teachers in Japan, I feel it is something that could benefit students later in life. Their feedback throughout this documentary was all high standard and reasonable for the students' success in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  27. I was taken aback with how the music teacher was treating the kids and let the girl cry in front of all her classmates. They even continue practicing while the student is crying in the room. I would think that the adults would at least usher her into another room to calm down. That would not slide my K-12 experience and the teacher would be reprimanded. I do enjoy how the students support each other in the classroom emotionally and with chores. Japanese schools have a deep focus on discipline and are preparing the kids for the demanding workforce.

    ReplyDelete

1/15…Labaree’s “Public Goods, Private Goods”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...