After looking over the VA Guidelines for Uniform Performance Standards and Evaluation Criteria for Teachers and the Greene article (from Forbes) what are your thoughts on teacher evaluation?
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1/15…Labaree’s “Public Goods, Private Goods”
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...
-
What do you make of Ayers' way of talking about teaching? Did he bring up any new/different ways of understanding the enterprise? Any ot...
-
Think back to your own experiences as a student. Can you identify any places where you see the influence of an asset approach. Can you recal...
I think that the current way that teachers are evaluated is wrong. Obviously nothing is entirely one way or the other. Not all the blame is on the teachers but it shoudn't all be on the students either. There's definitely a better system that needs to be put into place because the current one is unfair
ReplyDeleteI feel that teacher evaluation is a good thing for schools. It allows them to see which teachers are doing good and who is falling behind. However I feel like teachers are instead being judged instead of helped, making teachers who have bad feedback seem like a bad teacher, when they could just have a struggling class of kids.
ReplyDeleteOn paper teacher evaluation looks good, however there are downsides such as high stakes testing evaluation which basically keeps the teachers who score high and fire the teachers who score the lowest. This could cause there to be unnecessary rivalry between teachers and lack of teamwork among faculty. Teacher evaluation on the other hand has motivated educators to be as qualified as possible in the profession, improving teaching performance up to 0.11 standard deviations (4.5 percentile points). I feel as though teacher evaluation can be a good thing if executed properly.
ReplyDeleteThis is a little threatening to look at, it's like a glimpse into an evil future. A part that rubbed me the wrong way was "6.5 Engages in activities outside the classroom intended for school and student
ReplyDeleteenhancement" If teachers need to engage in activities outside of the classroom, are they getting paid for these after work actives??? I feel like no other job requires you to do something extra and then not actually pay you extra money for it. For the evaluation portion, the guidelines talk and talk about how important it is for the teachers to be evaluated and then in the next paragraph it talks about how it's a broken system that is difficult to determine and how the system "treat(s) them as interchangeable parts." This all seems pretty crazy to me.
I feel that evaluations are an essential process to better the individual and the organization. Therefore I do believe that these evaluations are a critical benefit to the teachers as well as to ensure the students are able to receive the most benefit they can from their teachers. I do believe that there could be more constructive criticism for the teachers. From what it seems and what i've witnessed it's more of a judging show than genuine assessment and development. Which doesn't help anybody. Teacher evaluations with genuine, developing, constructive criticism is an important and crucial process of betterment.
ReplyDeleteLike many government regulated things, it's outdated and doesn't work well. On Tuesday, we had an inspector come to my job. The regulations they use are outdated compared to what we are taught and what research in recent years states, yet, we are violating code if we don't follow regulations that are based on ten year old data. it's really frustrating because this system is causing a slow down in the overall process of education.
ReplyDeleteTeacher evaluation is important because it helps make sure students are getting a good education, but it should be fair and balanced. The Virginia guidelines show that teachers are judged on many things, like how they plan lessons, teach, and support students, which is good because teaching is more than just test scores. The Greene article suggests that some evaluation systems focus too much on results like student performance, which can miss other important parts of teaching. I think a strong evaluation system should include both student progress and what teachers do in the classroom, while also giving helpful feedback so teachers can improve instead of just judging them.
ReplyDeleteI don't think Teacher evaluation is a bad idea. I think their are a lot of teachers that because of their tenure go unsupervised and eventually stop adapting to the needs of new generations of students. However, I think that measuring a teachers performance based on how well their students test is the dumbest thing imaginable. Even if their were a "perfect test" that could gauge weather a student learned or not there are a billion factors as to why a student could have done poorly that are not the teachers fault.
ReplyDeleteAfter looking over the Virginia Guidelines for Uniform Performance Standards and Evaluation Criteria for Teachers and the Peter Greene article from Forbes, I think teacher evaluation is important, but it should be fair and helpful. The Virginia guidelines show that teachers are evaluated on many things, like planning, classroom environment, professionalism, and student progress. This makes sense because teaching is more than just test scores. Greene’s article made me think about how relying too much on test scores can be unfair, since many things that affect scores are outside a teacher’s control.
ReplyDeleteOverall, I think teacher evaluations are necessary, but they should focus on helping teachers improve, not just judging them. As a future teacher, evaluations make me a little nervous, but I also see them as a way to grow and become better at teaching.
After looking over the Virginia guidelines and the Greene article, one thing that stood out to me is how different teacher evaluation looks in theory vs real life. The guidelines are really structured and try to clearly define what “good teaching” is, which makes sense, but teaching isn’t something you can easily measure in a strict way since every class is different. The Greene article made me realize that things like test scores or quick observations don’t always show the full picture of what a teacher is actually doing. Overall, I think teacher evaluation is important, but it feels like it tries to simplify something that’s actually really complex, and that can end up putting pressure on teachers without always improving learning.
ReplyDeleteIt's good to have teacher evaluation, to make sure the teachers are doing what they are supposed to and to keep up the criteria and to meet expectations; it's just not flawless because some teachers would have horrible feedback even though they may struggle with the students in class and behavior.
ReplyDelete--Nevaeh Jordan
I do think teachers' evaluations are helpful and necessary to a certain level but I do think the way it is done is not the most effective. I also do agree with the fact that some evaluation systems seem outdated. Sometimes that does make the evaluation seem unfair and ineffective. However, I do think it is important but it can be done in a more effective way.
ReplyDeleteWe should not have people keeping close, judgmental eyes on our educators. But teacher evaluations can be a necessary advantage for teachers when used properly. Making them about the advancement, or rewarding teachers who need it would encourage them. It would also benefit students to have teachers who are constantly learning alongside them.
ReplyDeleteI think teacher evaluation should focus more on helping teachers grow than just judging them. The Virginia Department of Education guidelines seem useful for setting clear expectations, but they can feel too rigid and checklist driven. I agree with Peter Greene that teaching is too complex to measure with simple scores or data. In my opinion, the best evaluations would prioritize feedback, trust, and professional growth over strict ratings and scores.
ReplyDeleteI think that the evaluations are necessary, but I can also see how they can be potentially harmful for newer teachers who feel that they are falling behind and failing. However, I can see the glaringly obvious positive side that teachers can benefit from evaluations and can grow from the feedback. I think the best evaluations have feedback and can help a teacher grow without feeling entirely like a failure in their teachings.
ReplyDeleteI think teacher evaluation can be beneficial for schools because it helps identify which teachers are performing well and which ones may need support. However, it often feels more like teachers are being judged rather than guided. Negative feedback can make a teacher seem ineffective, when in reality they might just be working with a particularly challenging group of students.
ReplyDeleteThe way teacher evaluations are done are outdated and often ineffective. Thoughtful feedback can be given; although, the feedback can seem like it's putting the teacher down rather than uplifting the teacher. Feedback can be very iffy depending on how it's delivered because sometimes it'll make the teacher feel like they've failed their job while other feedback is encouraging and effective.
ReplyDeleteI think it’s a mix of good and bad, teacher evaluations can keep classrooms in check but they dont really help the teachers with what theyre “doing wrong”
ReplyDelete