Monday, January 12, 2026

3/31…Deficit and Asset Approaches (originally 3/19)

Think back to your own experiences as a student. Can you identify any places where you see the influence of an asset approach. Can you recall any deficit thinking in action? 

28 comments:

  1. My freshman year of highschool I was in this history class that was team taught and had a lot of struggling students that lacked basic note taking skills and things of that nature. Instead of conforming to pen and paper note taking to get kids to grasp the information better the teacher would use the room walls as paper writing on the cinder blocks with dry erase and would allow kids to do it well. It definitely was aggest school policy to do this because my teacher got many emails to stop which is the only way I can think of it being "deficit" that and not every class would have this as an opinion. But I highly enjoyed it because it warmed up students to more traditional note taking and relied on using student's creativity in a group of students where the creativity skill sets were much stronger than traditionally academic skill set.

    ReplyDelete
  2. When I think back on my time in gradeschool, I can definitely pick out a few moments where teachers were using more of an asset mindset, even though I didn’t have a name for it back then. I mostly noticed it in classes like English, where teachers actually wanted to hear what we thought. It wasn’t just about getting the right answer, it was more about how we interpreted things and what we brought into the discussion. That made a big difference for me because it felt like my ideas actually mattered, not just my ability to be correct. I also remember group projects where people had different roles and it wasn’t all about one type of “smart,” which made things feel more balanced. But honestly, I saw a lot more deficit thinking overall. The biggest example was tracking, like honors versus regular classes. It always felt like once you were put in a certain group, that kind of defined you, and teachers didn’t really expect much beyond that. You could tell the difference in how classes were taught and how much teachers pushed students. I also remember times where if someone was struggling, the first assumption was that they weren’t trying, instead of thinking about other reasons or different ways they might learn. Looking back, both mindsets were there, but the deficit thinking stuck out more because it shaped how people were viewed. The times teachers focused on what students could do instead of what they couldn’t just felt way more motivating and real.

    ReplyDelete
  3. In my government class at school, I remember when we were able to debate political topics in class and provide our own insights on the topic. I feel like that was an asset approach made by the teacher. We felt heard and instead of being “taught at” we were able to teach and direct ourselves as well. When I was in the 3rd grade I had just moved from Ohio, and I was in foster care. Because the teachers didn’t understand my experiences and because of my background prior to this they didn’t facilitate my learning as enthusiastically as the other students. I believe that this negatively affected my performance throughout the rest of elementary compared to my peers. I also believe that impacted how my future teachers saw me. Maybe not as capable as other students because what I “could not” do? This for me is an example of the deficit approach.

    ReplyDelete
  4. During my sophomore year of high school, I had an English teacher who really leaned into what students were already good at instead of focusing on what we struggled with. A lot of students in the class didn’t enjoy traditional essays or had trouble organizing their thoughts in writing. Instead of just labeling us as “bad writers,” she gave us options like creating visual storyboards, recording spoken responses, or even acting out scenes to show understanding of the material. This felt like an asset-based approach because she recognized that some students were stronger in creativity, speaking, or visual learning rather than just written expression. Over time, those activities actually helped build our confidence and made it easier to transition into more formal writing.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Throughout my high school experience, any time we were given a project with multiple allowed modalities were asset-based approaches. I remember in my sophomore year english class having a project on Beowulf where we could either write a paper or create an artistic interpretation of the scene. I think this is a practical way of focusing on assets rather than deficits as those who approach analysis differently can establish their ideas in a way that feels the most expressive to them. In terms of deficit-focused approaches, I think that too often the public school curriculum centers the gaps in knowledge or skills rather than establishing a healthy environment to develop them. I didn't interact with spanish speaking students in english learning programs at all. It's been proven that assimilation is most effective when learning a new language, so to alienate an entire subgroup into separate classes seems counteractive to the intended goal. I think this highlights one way that deficits are centered in schooling.

    ReplyDelete
  6. In my high school experience as an upperclassman, it was in English class, and it was an AP class. Everyone would assume the higher class was where the smart kids were; my AP English teacher was extremely lenient and understanding. He had extensions, had a deeper connection with the kids, and even though most wouldn't pay attention or just not care. He would give you a 50 instead of a 0 if you didn't even do the assignment. It was helping a lot, giving students enough time to put effort in and get good grades. That's until He couldn't do it anymore and didn't like how he gave more time and grading them in his free time,e even though it was aiding.
    --Nevaeh J.

    ReplyDelete
  7. In college, I saw an example of an asset approach in my UNIV 200 class. My teacher let us do our semester long project/ essay based on topics we were interested in or related to our major. This made the assignments feel more meaningful and showed that our interests and strengths actually mattered. It also made me more motivated to do the work because I could connect it to something I cared about. Another example I think of is one a lot of teachers do now I feel like, which is giving multiple ways to present information. For example, last week my teacher said we could either do a slideshow or an essay, and I picked slide show because I am better at doing slideshows compared to essays. This makes learning more personal and meaningful, I wish all assignments were like that.

    ReplyDelete
  8. During this school year I've witnessed an asset approach within Focused Inquiry and Sociology. In these classes our projects and most of the work was tailored to your interests which is our strengths in knowledge. This was helpful because instead of trying to learn and grasp something new to work upon, I was able to go more deeper and genuine in my work because it was where I was strongest knowledge wise. This approach also made me feel more inclined and favorable of the class cause it felt that the teacher values and considers my interests and strengths, rather than just ordering me.

    ReplyDelete
  9. In my senior year of high school, I took a class on Women’s History because I was very curious about it. It's the first time my school has had a class about most women in history. I love this class because I get to learn how to learn, how to accomplish what has made a difference in my life, other people's lives, and the world. In this class, my teacher always assigns a project in which we create a slideshow about women who changed their lives. It can be singers, shows, books, movies, etc. I love this assignment because I get to show what's important about the women who inspire me and change my life. This assignment shows an assertive approach, as I see different slide shows my classmates made on the topics of women who inspired them or the changes they made. Women’s History is a deficit because it shows that you don’t learn a lot about women in any history book or in school. I think this class shows that we need more classes that can make an impact on student life. I really enjoyed the slideshow I made in that class, and I put a lot of effort into it, including a lot of information about my topic, which I later changed.

    ReplyDelete
  10. My first year at community college, I had an amazing professor who used the asset approach when teaching public speaking. During this class, this professor first acknowledged the anxiety public speaking causes, making it something normal for students to experience/talk about. On the first day, our professor told the class that all of our public speaking speeches were to be on topics of our choosing, anything we wanted. His explanation was that it allowed us to choose topics we were both knowledgeable about, but also something we could confidently talk about. Not only did his use of the asset approach make the class a bit easier to participate in, but it also eased my anxiety when taking the class.

    ReplyDelete
  11. When I think back to being a student, I remember struggling a lot in speech class at first. I was nervous and not very confident speaking in front of others. At first, it felt like deficit thinking because I focused on what I couldn’t do. But my teacher used an asset approach by helping me build on small strengths, like practicing step by step and encouraging me instead of judging me. Because of that support, I improved a lot, and now I’m much better and more confident at speaking.

    ReplyDelete
  12. when I was a freshman in highschool, I had a new student come to my class. She had came from Colombia and didn’t know how to speak English. my highschool was a PWI and didn’t have much of diversity. my history teacher had then went out of her way to find a interpreter to translate what was said in class. she came every day for only our class. My teacher went into her own pocket to find help for her student so she could do her best in class, her using this asset approach helped the new student do better in her classes, and just shows a good examples of how strong good teachers care about their students.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Looking back, I definitely see both the asset approach and deficient thinking. In my high school chemistry class, I recall struggling, but the teacher employed an asset-based approach, teaching step-by-step instructions that greatly aided my understanding of the material and helped me succeed in the class. Another experience I had was in my freshman year of college, when my UNIV professor would assign essays that we were interested in, which made it easier for me to delve deeper into and showcase my strengths in areas that truly mattered to me. On the other hand, I have seen deficient thinking where students who struggle are viewed as lacking effort. This mindset is honestly discouraging for the students' growth.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Thinking back on school, I can see how race played a role how my teachers thought. There were times when teachers used an asset approach, like letting me connect assignments to my identity and experiences as a Black student. That made me feel seen and like my voice actually mattered.
    But I’ve also experienced deficit thinking, like when teachers had lower expectations for Black students or assumed we weren’t trying as hard. Those moments made it clear how quickly people can judge based on race.
    Overall, those experiences showed me how important it is for teachers to see students’ backgrounds as strengths instead of limitations.

    ReplyDelete
  15. During my time in school, I've had teachers use the asset approach many times. The class would typically do better when everyone would use their cultural experiences and/or passions to complete assignments, rather than being told completely what to do. English and U.S. History class were the primary courses I remember asset approach being used in, because we had a lot more freedom to complete assignments based on how we saw and understood them best, instead of a traditional approach that not everyone would be great with.

    On the other hand, I experienced the deficit approach much more from people outside of the school, yet still worked in the school system, and even some teachers. I remember doing an interview once with someone from the county, and when he came back to tell the students that we succeeded, he specifically said he didn't think the students at our school would be very good based on our reputation. The mindset that students that live or attend school in a certain area, especially based on demographics, makes them unmotivated or not "as smart" is the worst way to approach any students, and truthfully causes some to embrace the mindset if they believe people don't have standards for them.

    ReplyDelete
  16. I’ve seen many more professors try an asset approach compared to my high school teachers. I think that is partly because high school teachers are restricted by the curriculum and how it should be taught a certain way. Even down to assignments where the entire English department has to give a specific assignment with a set of rules that cannot be changed. In college I have been given more freedom to choose the topics I want to talk about in my writing. Group discussions are a lot more lively as well. It feels like professors actually want my input on what I think about topics that are being discussed. High school teachers would try to implement the asset approach, but at the end of the day they had to strictly follow the curriculum. There were times though where we had group discussions, it just didn’t seem like the class was invested enough for there to be any meaningful conversation.

    ReplyDelete
  17. An example of the asset approach of teaching was in my sophomore year history class. My teacher encouraged all of us to share our unique views on American History and encouraged us to listen to different perspectives to better understand the material. He also encouraged us to use "skills" that we use in real life to become more interested in history. He said that the stuff we are learning is similar to gossip and we should treat it like drama so we would be more interested in the material.

    ReplyDelete
  18. My US History teacher used an asset approach by putting on trials and pitting us against each other. He used our argumentative and competitive nature as teens to influence us into learning enough to hold up in debate. My guitar teacher used an asset approach by putting on a rockfest at the end of the year. (we play classical music most of the year). She used our love for rock fest and performance to encourage us to learn harder music. I think almost all of my math teachers used a deficit approach, they'd only focus on what we don't know and trying to encode it into our brains.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I think most of my high school classes relied on asset teaching. They heard the right answer from other students in the class and immediately thought that EVERYONE understood. I see this in subjects like math. The deficit approach happened in a lot of my AP classes as many of them focused on what we DONT know

    ReplyDelete
  20. From what I remember my US history class my junior year made us do projects based on things we knew. She made sure she knew by having a bunch of different types of topics we could choose from ensuring everybody knew something.


    A deficit that I can remember is in my child parenting class, my teacher made us take a quiz on how much we knew about babies and then taught the course based off that.

    ReplyDelete
  21. I believe that we all go through this and I did go through this a lot in school. Mostly in high school in elementary school, I dealt with this but once I went to middle school, my teachers mostly wanted other students to understand and wanted to give everyone a chance even if the answer was right or wrong, we would go through everyone answer and it made us understand better.

    ReplyDelete
  22. I had an English teacher in high school who was really good at using the asset approach. She would ensure to leave positive feedback as well as constructive criticism and focus mostly on the ways in which current existing skills can be used to strengthen the places in which our writing was weaker. She made us feel like good writers no matter what as long as the effort was there, and helped to actually refine our skills. The deficit thinking existed in many of my math classes as it is a bit more of a black and white subject so it was difficult to frame any feedback in an encouraging way, however it definitely is possible.

    ReplyDelete
  23. An asset based learning experience I've had is in my pre-calc class, the teacher would present us with a new concept and then we would have small groups where we would do problems together. this was very helpful because we could work on problems in a low stress environment and if I knew something a classmate didn't then I would help them and vis versa.

    ReplyDelete
  24. I see a lot of asset approaches to teaching being a sociology major. A lot of what I do is research or research based projects. Once we got past the point of learning how to do basic research, it has been a lot of letting students decide what they want to research, how they want to research, and how they want to present their research. I think that giving students this freedom really allows for everyone to excel because they get to look into things that they are interested in and present in a format that they think is most effective rather than just like MLA format or whatever the teacher wants. My high school sociology teacher was really good at this and was a big reason why I chose to major in sociology. Maybe she had a looser curriculum to follow than core classes and that's why she was able to give us more freedom in the classroom, but every student in that class was engaged and giving it their all, and I think the asset sort of approach really played a big role in that.

    ReplyDelete
  25. I took a class at UVA the summer after my freshman year that was more of helping a professor with their research. Despite it being two weeks, it was really conducive and felt as though it fit into the asset category. We spent time giving lectures, but mostly we used our strengths in our individual areas of expertise to create models for transporting greywater through the slums of Ciaro. Probably one of the best classes I've ever taken and one of the main reasons I have studied water pollution and water scarcity since, and made my minor in environmental studies.

    ReplyDelete
  26. In my senior year in my Biology class, my teacher really focused on improving on the smaller skills that students really struggled with, which was something that my other teachers didn't tend to do in my other classes. I found that although I had many failures in learning the harder concepts of Biology, they ended up sticking in my head for a lot longer than other subjects because of the way that my teacher reinforced the positive sides of failure and learning as opposed to letting us be beaten by the failures.

    ReplyDelete
  27. During my sophomore year of high school, I had an English teacher who focused on our strengths rather than our weaknesses. Many students in the class didn’t enjoy traditional essays or found it difficult to organize their ideas in writing. Instead of labeling us as “bad writers,” she offered alternative ways to demonstrate our understanding, such as creating visual storyboards, recording spoken responses, or acting out scenes.

    ReplyDelete

1/15…Labaree’s “Public Goods, Private Goods”

In this post, please provide: 1. one takeaway (one specific thing that you learned from a very quick read of the article and; 2. Ask a quest...